Based on the request of so many architects and consultants, we
are pleased to list below the most common questions asked about
choosing the right kind of elevators, and other questions
related to the installation of elevators. We have tried our best
to answer the most of the frequently asked questions, however,
as every question & answer cannot be incorporated below, and
that every project situation is unique to site conditions and
customer requirement, we strongly recommend contacting our sales
department for a comprehensive reply from our engineering
department. Typically, any query posed to us can be answered in
1-2 business days. We welcome your questions, and we will be
pleased to answer in a timely manner. Therefore, please send us
an email at sales@expresselp.com, or feel free to call us at +1
(647) 505-0023.
Passenger Elevators
Freight Elevating Devices
In the province of Ontario (and some of the other
provinces & territories for that matter), the Elevator
Act allows for installation of a Materials Lift (commonly
known as a Freight Lift or Freight Platform Lift) between
levels with a maximum travel of 7.62 m (25 feet). However,
if the travel is higher than 7.62 m (25 feet), then it
mandates the provision of a Freight Elevator to carry
goods between two or more fixed levels.
As compared to a Freight Elevator, both Materials Lifts
and Dumbwaiters require a smaller footprint. However, a
Dumbwaiter can carry a maximum load of 227 Kg (500 lbs),
with a maximum Dumbwaiter cab size of 914 mm (36”)
wide X 914 mm (36”) long X 1219 mm (48”) high.
In case the goods to be carried are heavier than 227 Kg
(500 lbs), or larger than the size mentioned above, then a
Dumbwaiter would not be a suitable choice. In that
situation, a Materials Lift would have to be provided. We
would like to further mention that a Material Lift can
only travel up to a maximum of 7.62 m (25 feet) of travel
distance. However, there is no travel restriction for a
Dumbwaiter. Hope above helps you in making the suitable
choice for your project.
Based on our experience each freight vertical
transportation application is unique and requires
consideration of following factors: • The size &
magnitude of the load • Traffic pattern, frequency
usage & speed of the elevator • The method of
loading into the elevator cab • Type of hoistway
shaft and enclosure construction • Fire separation
between the levels and habitable space beneath the pit
slab • Is it possible to cut the slab and form a pit
at the bottom landing • Type of entrances required
• Special conditions like water-tight, exposure to
elements of weather, flame-proof, and explosion-proof
equipment We strongly recommend contacting our sales
department for a project-specific design proposal. We will
be happy to suggest the most suitable solution after
considering all relevant variables.
Yes, this is correct. Materials lift is available in both
Canada and the US. Materials lift, commonly known as a
Freight Lift in Canada, is governed under Elevator Code
CSA B44, and hence is an elevating device. However, in
USA, Material Lift, commonly known as a Vertical
Reciprocating Conveyor (VRC), is governed by the B20
material handling code of the USA. The Material Lift in
Canada may or may not allow a rider on the platform,
whereas the Vertical Reciprocating Conveyor available in
the US strictly do not allow for any rider on the
carriage. A Vertical Reciprocating Conveyor may not be
permissible by jurisdictions in various provinces &
territories of Canada to carry loads between two fixed
levels with 2 meters or more travel. Therefore, it is very
important to qualify the product very carefully. If you
have any questions or concerns, please feel free to
contact our design department or the authority having
jurisdiction (AHJ) of that province.
Type A Materials Lift are meant strictly to carry goods
with no rider on the platform of the lift. Type B
Materials Lifts allow for a freight handler to ride inside
the elevator. Since there is no rider permissible, a Type
A Materials Lift can travel faster and higher than a Type
B Materials Lift. However, a Type A Materials Lift may
require a pit. Only after understanding the end user
requirement and other site conditions, a decision should
be made between the type of Material Lifts.
Considering the safety of the freight handler and to
enable safe transportation of goods, the Elevator Code
stipulates the use of a legal freight elevating device to
transport goods between two fixed levels. Therefore, any
other means, such as an unguided hoist arrangement from
the top, or an unguided scissors lift, is not considered a
legal means of freight transportation. Every time an
elevator inspector finds such an arrangement, he/she is
liable to shut and seal such an installation. Therefore,
the use of such arrangements is not permissible, as it can
often lead to unsafe situations.
As mentioned in the reply to the question above, this is
not a legal arrangement as it does not meet the criteria
laid down in elevating code, and therefore, this
arrangement is considered illegal. Such arrangement can
lead to an unsafe situation, wherein the management and
the end user can be held liable, therefore such an
arrangement can’t be used.
Automobile Elevators
Please note that any automobile elevator is designed with
class B loading. Considering the axle load and the wheel
base of a typical automobile (ranging from a sedan to an
SUV), the loading of an automobile elevator is of moderate
nature, and is not suitable for point concentrated loading
designed for a freight elevator meant to carry a forklift
truck with a load on it. Therefore, an automobile elevator
is simply not designed to carry a heavy, concentrated load
such as a transformer or a forklift truck. As a matter of
fact, it is considered illegal to load a forklift truck
beyond its rated load capacity and its class of loading.
Any elevator which breaks down due to excessive loading
needs to be reported immediately to the elevating
contractor servicing the elevator, and they may be
obligated to report it further to the authority having
jurisdiction (AHJ). Therefore, we strongly recommend
loading any elevating device as per its permissible
loading. When in doubt, ask the elevator contractor who
manufactured or installed the unit, or who is currently
maintaining the unit. Feel free to contact us for any
specific installation.
As the name suggests, Parking Stackers are used to stack
one automobile above the other, thus reducing the
footprint and enabling a larger number of automobiles to
be parked on a certain footprint. Depending on the
available Ceiling Height or available Pit Depth, two or
more automobiles can be stacked vertically, one above the
other. More complex designs allowing horizontal movement
of automobiles enables faster & efficient storage
& retrieval of automobiles which can be provided as
Semi or Fully Automated Systems, thus enabling
auto-parking and auto-retrieval of the vehicle. An
Automobile Elevator is used to transport the automobile
between 2 or more fixed floors. In line with Elevator Code
CSA B44, any Automobile Elevator needs to be provided with
a guided platform and other features required for any
Freight Elevator as stipulated in the Elevator Code CSA
B44 .
As mentioned above, the purpose of stackers is solely to
park one automobile above the other. Therefore, a stacker
cannot be used to deliver cars from one floor to the
other. Only an automobile elevator can be used to
transport automobiles between levels, as they are provided
with a guided system and have other required features from
the Elevator Code.
Accessibility Devices
As the name suggests, a LULA elevator is called Limited
Use Limited Application, wherein the capacity of the
elevator is limited to 1,400 lbs, and the speed is limited
to only 30 feet per minute. If the primary intent is to
provide barrier free access to the building without speed
and/ or elevator cab size of the elevator of being any
consequence, then a LULA elevator could be installed.
However, if this elevator will be significantly used with
higher levels of traffic in the elevator lobby, then a
passenger elevator is preferred. Although a LULA elevator
offers significant savings as it has a shallower 14”
pit, with no requirement for a drain and a sump pump in
the shaft, it offers limitations of speed, cab size &
area and load capacity. Therefore, the final selection of
the product should be carefully done after considering all
the variables and doing a traffic analysis in consultation
between the end user and the elevator consultant.
A LULA Elevator and an Accessibility Lift both fulfill the
barrier free vertical transportation between two or more
levels. For a LULA elevator, the maximum speed of the
elevating device is limited to 30 feet per minute, whereas
an accessibility lift the speed may vary between 15 feet
and 30 feet per minute. However, the two distinctions
which add a major difference to the end user are that the
LULA elevator does not have restricted access, and it
moves with momentary push button operation. Furthermore,
the entrances for the LULA elevator are automatic sliding
doors, just like any other passenger elevator. As per the
code requirement, an Accessibility Platform Lift, always
has restricted access typically provided by a key override
switch. Therefore a means to obtain assistance is required
in order to allow for use of an Accessibility Lift. The
doors are either manual or power operated swing doors.
Above factors need to be considered before arriving at the
decision on the choice of the suitable product. In our
opinion, it is best to contact our sales department for a
project specific consultation.
A Vertical Platform Lift is usually preferred over an
Inclined Platform Lift, provided there is dedicated
vertical space between the levels to provide a hoistway
shaft for the platform lift to move vertically up and
down. Many times, in an existing building, it is difficult
or even impossible to create a vertical column of space
between two or three levels due to the existing building
plan limitations at various levels, or due to existing
amenities on various floors. In those situations, an
Inclined Platform Lift is installed over a flight of
stairs to provide barrier-free accessibility between the
levels.
A chairlift requires a person to sit on the seat of the
Chairlift and climb up and down on an inclined path above
a flight of stairs. So the rider if he/ she is on a
wheelchair would have to physically leave the wheelchair
to hop of the Chairlift. This may not be possible for some
people in wheelchair. The advantage that the Inclined
Platform Lift offers is that the rider does not have to
leave his/her wheelchair, as that the wheelchair can move
(roll) onto the platform of the Inclined Platform Lift,
and can be carried up and down above the flight of stairs.
Installation of the Inclined Platform Lift is more
elaborate as it requires greater magnitude of
reinforcement to the building support. Comparatively, the
installation is more time consuming and the project cost
is more expensive for an Inclined Platform Lift.
Hydraulic Elevators
Both Buried and Non Buried designs are equally reliable
and give the same level of performance if installed and
maintained properly. It is always easier to install a
buried cylinder for a new construction where the building
is just at the grade level of construction, thereby the
boring machine can be brought very close to the proposed
hoistway pit. PVC lining with the buried cylinder ensures
that the buried design is completely environmentally
friendly. However, where a building is already existing,
due to access reasons and structural reasons, it can be a
challenge to bore a hole for a buried cylinder. Therefore,
a Non Buried Design, whether Telescopic or a Roped Design
could be preferred. Feel free to contact our design
department with specific project details for further
information.
A Telescopic design requires a deeper pit and taller
overhead height. It also allows for direct coupling
between the hydraulic sling and the car platform assembly,
thus giving a robust design. Due to the direct coupling,
no rope break safety device or rope slack safety device is
required. This also eliminates the need for certain tests
to be performed periodically. Telescopic cylinders are
reliable and available with the oil seals, lasting many
years before requiring replacement. However, in case pit
depth and/ or the over head height is not sufficient, then
a roped design would be the way to go. Both options
perform equally well if installed and maintained properly.
These days the available cylinders are extremely reliable,
and the oil seals are reliable as well, lasting many years
before requiring any replacement.
Yes, it is always preferred to have the machine room
constructed just adjacent to the hoistway shaft at the
bottom most landing. Ideally, there should always be a
common wall between the hoistway shaft and the machine
room so that the length and scope of the hydraulic,
electrical and the communication lines can be minimized.
However, if there are any building functional constraints,
then the machine room can be located remote to the hoist
way shaft as well. There have been instances where the
machine room has been located as far as 50 feet away from
the hoistway shaft. However, this will result in certain
head loss in the hydraulic pressure, and will also result
in turbulence and eddy currents in the hydraulic line.
Besides distance between the hoistway shaft and the
machine room, care should be taken to minimize the number
of bends and turns in the hydraulic lines, as otherwise
this results in the further increase of turbulence in the
hydraulic line.
Machine Room Less (MRL) Elevator
Please note that typically for up to 5 or 6 stop buildings
with a travel of 15.24 m (about 50 feet) a Hydraulic
design is preferred as it allows for flexible location of
the machine room, thus lowering the height of the hoistway
shaft and the total height of the building. Hydraulic
equipment is self-lubricating and easier to install and
maintain. For travel more than 15.24 m (50 feet) Machine
Room Less elevator is preferred. Although both Hydraulic
and MRL are reliable and can provide similar level of
performance, however MRL elevator has more starts per hour
and thus is more robust machine. Since the final choice of
type of machine depends on various factors like the usage
of building (commercial/ residential), number of elevators
in the building, traffic rate & pattern, duty load
(load capacity and speed), it is always advisable to
consult our sales department, where in after considering
all the variables, we should be able to give you a prompt
response.
The machine for the MRL (machine room less) elevator is
located at the overhead area at the top of the hoistway,
therefore it is always preferred to have the controller at
the topmost landing adjacent to the hoistway shaft, thus
minimizing the extent of wiring and conduiting.
Furthermore, the close vicinity of the controlled to the
machine also allows for speedy installation and subsequent
maintenance and trouble shooting.
Hoistway Shafts & Machine Room
A hoisting beam allows for a safer installation as any
elevator part & component can be safely and legally
hoisted, supported/ tied off from the top (to the hoisting
beam) before it gets anchored to the shaft walls or the
pit floor. The installers working on the scaffold inside
the hoistway shaft are wearing body harnesses, the
lifelines of which are typically secured to the hooks
coming out of the hoisting beam. In line with Ministry of
Labour and OSHA requirement, it is essential that any
mechanic or person working on heights is wearing proper
PPE (personal protective equipment), including a legal,
CSA approved body harness, and his/ her lift line is tied
off safely to the secured hoisting hooks/ points.
Furthermore, during the course of the usage of the
elevator, major repair work or modernization might be
required to the elevator. At that time the hoisting beams
available at the top of the shaft, are used to secure and
tie elevator car or other major components like the
machine, cylinder, and crosshead. This helps in major
parts repair or replacement. Therefore, it is essential
that a hoisting beam of suitable load carrying capacity,
as determined by the structural engineer, is provided by
the owner before the start of installation.
Material of the hoistway shaft construction is chosen by
the architect on the project after considering the
magnitude of the forces from the elevator equipment on the
shaft walls and pit floor. As an elevator contractor, we
would always specify the magnitude of the force from guide
rails, cylinders/ elevator machine, pit buffers. Based on
these forces your structural engineer would make the
choice ofmaterial for hoistway shaft construction. For
certain light load applications, such as for home
elevators or accessibility lifts, a stack of 2” x
10” lumber or 2” x 12” lumber planks
with plywood layering can be used for hoistway
construction. For moderate to heavy loading masonry blocks
are provided. The hollow blocks to be carefully filled
with rebar, mortar, and concrete, to provide adequate
strength to the wall. Through bolting to secure the rail
bracket to be done on the filled masonry walls. For
heavier passenger and freight elevators, precast concrete
walls or reinforced concrete walls are most suitable. The
advantage of using precast concrete walls or reinforced
concrete walls is that besides providing strength, they
also provide the fire separation required between floors.
In some instances where a metal fabrication is preferred,
structural engineers typically design the shaft using a
150 mm (6”) x 150 mm (6”) or 200 mm (8”)
x 200 mm (8”) hollow structural steel tube (HSS),
and then a site certified welder (provided by others),
welds the rails bracket to these tubes. Later, glazing
panel or solid or expanded metal enclosure can be provided
to enclose the hoistway shaft. The final composition of
the hoistway shaft takes into account structural
integrity, fire separation, any other variables as
determined by the owners, therefore the final decision on
the choice of the shaft is carefully made by the architect
and the structural engineer of the project.
As mentioned in answer above, the final composition of the
hoistway shaft is determined by the architect and the
structural engineer, after taking into account the rail
bracket loading and considering other factors such as fire
separation, structural integrity of the shaft.Also we
would need to determine if 1 of 3 elevators to be a
dedicated fire fighters elevators and therefore might
require a fire rated separator wall. Please forward us a
set of building drawing for further review.
If there is access directly beneath the hoistway shaft,
then that space is called a habitable space below the
shaft. In order for this space to be legally accessible
and usable, the pit floor slab needs to be reinforced
suitably with an added factor of safety. The magnitude of
thisforce is determined by the reaction force on the
buffers installed on the pit floor. Therefore, it is very
important to contact the elevator contractor, and
determine the magnitude of force on the pit floor slab to
enable the structural engineer to design the pit floor. If
the pit floor is adequately reinforced, and pit buffers
with the required stroke are provided by the elevator
contractor, then the space directly beneath the hoistway
shaft is usable. Otherwise, you may be forced to enclose
the space directly beneath the hoistway shaft.
Machine room equipment, whether for hydraulic or for
traction equipment, have a certain heat dissipation. This
impacts the PLC control of the controller of the elevator,
and can also impact the viscosity of the oil in case of
hydraulic equipment. Furthermore, the elements of the
weather and the resulting ambient temperature in the
building also have an impact on the elevator equipment.
Therefore, it is very important to know the required
ambient temperature range and the relative humidity range
suitable for the elevator equipment, both for the hoistway
shaft, and for the machine room. Also after taking into
account the heat dissipation of the unit, adequate heating
and/ orcooling needs to be provided in the machine room
and hoistway shaft. The means could be as simple as
providing a louvre in the machine room door or as
elaborate as providing an air conditioner and/ or a
baseboard heater with a thermostat & fan assembly in
the machine room. Furthermore, heating might be required
for hoistway shafts exposed to the elements of the
weather. This subject is further addressed in the next
question.
Elevator code and building code may allow for an entrance
to open to the exterior, provided there is no conflict
with fire separation or any other conflict with the
elevator and/ or building code. Furthermore, it is very
important for the elevator equipment that none of the
elevator parts or components are exposed directly to the
elements of the weather, such as temperature variation,
condensation, humidity, various types of precipitation,
excessive wind etc. In case any of these elements directly
impacts the elevator equipment, then either water-tight or
NEMA 4X equipment needs to be part of the elevator, or a
vestibule should be provided in front of the elevator.
Typically, it is possible to provide NEMA 4X weatherproof
equipment for certain passenger elevators or larger
freight elevators, but it may not be possible to provide
such provisions for smaller equipment, like dumbwaiters.
Therefore, please qualify the site conditions very
carefully, so that a suitable elevating device can be
proposed and installed for your project.
Please note that every passenger elevator and freight
elevator is provided with firefighters service phase 1
& phase 2. In case if any ofthe fire alarm initiating
device (FAID) is triggered, then the elevator moves to the
fire recall level, and then if required, the phase 2
firefighters service can be initiated by a firefighter. In
the phase 2 fire service mode, firefighters have exclusive
access to the elevator, and can run the elevator up and
down in the building to rescue any trapped occupants. In
case of a building fire, the sprinklers get triggered and
the hose pipes are also activated. There is always the
fear of water accumulating in the lower portion of the
building and the hoistway shaft pits are usually one of
the lowest levels in the building. Accumulation of water
in a pit is a very serious hazard. Therefore, it is
mandatory to provide a pump of a certain minimum capacity
to drain out water at a certain minimum rate in order to
maintain a safe condition.
For heavier elevators with machines more than 5
horsepower, 3 phase power supply is required. It is always
recommended to choose higher voltage as it results in
lower amperage, lower GA wiring, lower rating for
disconnect box, and lower fuse ratings. This eventually
helps in lower material cost and running cost for the
elevator.